Science Policy Fellowship: Resilience to Fluvial Flooding: Knowns and Unknowns to Recommendations for Management
CREW Code: CSPF2023_02
Theme: Hydrological Extremes, Coasts and Risk Management
Type of project: CREW Science Policy Fellowship
Project Status: Project complete. Click here to visit the publication page to view the project outputs.
Lead research team: Heriot-Watt University
In this Science Policy Fellowship, the research team aimed to critique what we know and don’t know about fluvial flood risk, resilience and management. The research team used the epistemological construct of “known knowns, known unknowns and unknown unknowns” to assess both scientific and stakeholder knowledge. The team conducted a Rapid Evidence Assessment utilising the power of AI to synthesise thousands of papers and to produce network visualisations of keywords and conducted a workshop with key stakeholders. Four themes emerged; 1) Climate Change; 2) Flood Generating Hydrology; 3) Natural Flood Management; and 4) Stakeholder Engagement.
This project has completed. Click here to visit the publication page to view the project outputs.
Science Policy Fellowship: Building Public Health Resilience to Fluvial Flooding in Scotland
CREW Code: CSPF2023_01
Theme: Hydrological Extremes, Coasts and Risk Management
Type of project: CREW Science Policy Fellowship
Project Status: Project complete. Click here to visit the publication page to view the project outputs.
Lead research team: University of Glasgow
Climate change is increasing our exposure to fluvial flooding in Scotland. Physical and mental health are negatively impacted by flooding, with the greatest health impacts in the UK and Scotland on mental health. This CREW Policy Brief reviews the literature on the public health impacts of fluvial flooding, including physical and mental health impacts, and identifies factors that influence health resilience to flooding.
Key Scottish flood-related and public health policies were analysed to identify knowledge gaps and mechanisms to incorporate public health resilience to fluvial flooding in Scotland. To build health resilience in Scotland the reseach team recommend that further research is undertaken to understand health impacts on vulnerable groups (knowing who, where and when) and to implement this knowledge into localised flood emergency management, as a public health priority.
This project has completed. Click here to visit the publication page to view the project outputs.
CREW will be hosting a workshop in collaboration with three CREW Science Policy Fellowship projects:
Workshop 1 River Flooding, Management and Resilience: The Knowns and Unknowns. Research lead: Ian Pattison, Heriot Watt University
Workshop 2 Policy to Preparedness: Pluvial and fluvial flooding, perceptions, and potential behaviour change. Research lead: Fiona Henderson, Glasgow Caledonian University
Workshop 3 Building public health resilience to fluvial flooding in Scotland. Research lead: Rhian Thomas, University of Glasgow
Reflections during the day will assist in the production of three short briefing papers, which will support the development of Scotland’s first Flood Resilience Strategy.
Promoting water reuse
New publication: Making waves: Promoting municipal water reuse without a prevailing scarcity driver
The article below has been provided to CREW by the report authors: Dominic Duckett, Mads Troldborg, Sarah Hendry, Hubert Cousins
Talk to a Scot about water reuse and you may encounter bewilderment. ‘We don’t need water recycling in Scotland: It rains all the time’! Indeed, the abundance of water in our natural environment coupled with high precipitation makes many people in Scotland and other ‘wet’ parts of the world, question the need for water efficiency. However, efficient use of our precious water is something that everyone ought to take seriously. Our new paper makes the case for greater water reuse here and now.
We are facing a Climate Emergency yet we use non-renewable energy to purify water beyond what is necessary for many uses. For example, we wastefully wash vehicles and water our gardens with water processed to drinking water standards. Furthermore, the provision of safe water is a process that requires significant investment in infrastructure to capture, treat, store and distribute it, all of which incur a carbon footprint. Ageing infrastructure and increasing demands combine to strengthen the argument for provisioning water efficiently and recycling it where appropriate not wasting it.
Hydronation scholar Hubert Cousin https://www.dundee.ac.uk/people/hubert-cousin is working to bring about the changes that we believe are necessary to make Scotland a world leader in this reuse endeavour. His research aims to identify barriers to the implementation of a water reuse policy in Scotland and promote solutions to overcome them.
Perhaps unsurprisingly, the wealth of water reuse research has concentrated around scarcity and/or rapid urbanisation contexts. There is nothing like water shortage to focus hearts and minds on alternative supply arrangements. Thankfully, desperately needed progress has been achieved in contexts of scarcity although huge global challenges remain. Less progress has been achieved in water rich contexts; a fact illustrated by the lack of change on the ground in countries like Scotland. Without the driving force of scarcity, no other catalyst has come close to incentivising water recycling to the same extent. To advance municipal scale reuse projects in locations where scarcity is not forcing the issue, for example here in Scotland, there is a need to predicate water reuse on different drivers, specifically the Climate Emergency (which Scotland was among the first nations to declare) and the circular economy. While alternative drivers remain relatively weak, barriers appear intractable preventing progress towards water recycling. The law around water incorporates complex regulatory frameworks often proving intransigent; Public trust in the safety and equity of reforms is easily eroded with operators not enjoying the confidence of end users; The so-called yuck factor describes an instinctive repugnance to the idea of using recycled water. These barriers are critically reviewed in the new paper. The battering ram of scarcity demolishes obstacles but without it much greater ingenuity and effort is required to mobilise reform.
Of course, there are growing scarcity concerns in Scotland with disruptions to supply occurring more frequently with extreme weather events and the changing climate. However, we argue, in our new paper (https://doi.org/10.1016/j.watres.2023.120965) , for new approaches and new arguments to be advanced making the case for recycling where scarcity is not an imperative. The notion of a ‘yum’ factor, whereby positive sentiments are nurtured to combat instinctive repugnance is advanced as a strategic objective to promote more rapid expansion of municipal scale reuse. We also welcome the Scottish Government’s water, wastewater and drainage policy consultation and hope our research can contribute to effective policy development.
Water, Wastewater & Drainage Policy Consultation
The consultation seeks views on the Scottish Government’s proposed principles and considerations in developing policy for the future of the water industry in Scotland in response to the climate emergency.
Responses can be made using the Scottish Government’s consultation hub, Citizen Space (http://consult.gov.scot).
You can access and respond to this consultation online at https://consult.gov.scot/energy-and-climate-change-directorate/water-was....
CRW2023_09 Methodologies for sampling fish populations in Scottish freshwater lochs
CREW Code: CRW2022_09
Theme: Hydrological Extremes, Coasts and Risk Management
Project status: Project complete. Click here to visit the publication page to view the project outputs.
Type of project: Capacity Building
Lead research team: University of the Highlands and Islands (UHI)
An understanding of the fish species present and their abundance in Scottish lochs is required for management and conservation purposes, and also to fulfil regulatory requirements. Furthermore, the recent increase in pumped storage hydro-electric development proposals involving large freshwater lochs has the potential to create additional pressures on fish populations. In order to address this, it is important that fish populations are properly assessed during environmental impact assessments and scoping. While a variety of established methods for fish monitoring exist, there is no ’one size fits all’ method, therefore careful consideration is needed in order to determine the best approaches to monitoring. It is therefore important that we have an understanding of the ecological data requirements, and how best to attain these across space and time in order to ensure that fish populations in Scottish freshwater lochs are adequately protected.
The aim of this project was to assess the currently available methodologies for sampling fish populations in Scottish freshwater lochs. Acknowledging the complexity and longstanding challenges with fish monitoring in standing freshwaters, the main objective here was to produce guidelines which support the development of suitable fish assessment programmes.
This project has completed. Click here to visit the publication page to view the project outputs.
CREW Science Policy Fellowships
Type of project: CREW Science Policy Fellowship
Overview: CREW Science Policy Fellowships intend to support evidence-based decisions by providing the opportunity for Scotland’s research community to advocate for critical science that addresses upcoming water-related policy, regulatory and/or industry needs. This ‘research-push’ workstream compliments CREW’s ‘policy-pull’ Capacity Building and Call Down workstreams in facilitating exchanges of expert knowledge between Scottish Higher Education Institutes (HEIs) and Research Institutes, and policymakers, regulators, and industry representatives.
Eligibility: CREW Science Policy Fellowship funding is open to applications from all relevant Scottish HEIs and Research Institutes (approved subcontractors). Approved subcontractors have received a copy of CREW’s Terms and Conditions. CREW encourages applications from experienced to early career researchers (ECRs) under the supervision and mentorship of experienced researchers.
Autumn 2023: CREW commissioned three Science Policy Fellowships which are aligned to, and support, the development of Scotland’s first Flood Resilience Strategy.
Project Status: All projects complete.
Please use the links below to access the project outputs for each project:
Building Public Health Resilience to Fluvial Flooding in Scotland
Policy to Preparedness: Flood Policy and Community Engagement
Resilience to Fluvial Flooding: Knowns and Unknowns to Recommendations to Management
Register of Expertise for the water sector
CREW's Register of Expertise
Connecting opportunity and capability in water science and policy
Visit register.crew.ac.uk
• Connect to opportunities
• Reach out to colleagues and share your work
• Explore skills and find solutions
• Widen your network
CREW's water sector Register of Expertise was launched on World Water Day March 22nd 2023.
Learn all about it here!
Aim: The Register of Expertise aims to:
- support colleagues in the Scottish water community access information on water experts and expertise;
- provide a platform to increase visibility and interconnectedness when searching for new project consortia and wider collaborations; and
- facilitate a network of expertise from academia, industry, regulation, and policy.
Development: The project was annouced at a CREW engagement workshop with Higher Education Institutes and Research Institutes, and suggestions and feedback was taken on board. A scoping study reviewed the evidence base on contemporary research taxonomies, related methodologies and technical characteristics and functionality of a range of online expert-finding systems.
Find an Expert: The Register of Expertise contains information on who relevant experts are, where they are working, what role, research expertise, experience, and skills they possess and how they contribute to CREW projects and Scotland’s science: policy interface on water. Search by (a combination of) Geographical region of research operations, specialist areas, environmental sector, discipline, technology, role or by name!
Register: Researchers and practitioners alike can register in seven steps from a mobile phone or computer. Accounts are verified by the CREW team, then users can complete their profiles and update them at any time. Users can also link to their existing profiles and identifiers (e.g., LinkedIn, ResearchGate, Orchid) and reference key CREW publications and wider outputs.
If you have any queries about the Register, please email RoECoordinator@crew.ac.uk
CRW2023_07 Increasing flood resilience: residential and community rainwater run-off retention solutions
CREW Code: CRW2023_09
Project status: Project complete. Click here to visit the publication page to view the project outputs.
Type of project: Capacity Building
Lead research team: Abertay University
In recent years there has been an increased awareness of the need to address surface water runoff in urban environments. This includes understanding where flood risks may arise, increase, or change in the future due to climate change and increased urban creep, the increased conversion of gardens and other vegetated areas which help to soak up rain. To support resilient surface water management in urban environments, the identification, efficacy, cost effectiveness and prioritisation of implementable flood risk management solutions is essential.
This project evaluated and compared the cost and effectiveness of residential and community property rainwater runoff source control solutions to increase flood resilience. Source control Sustainable Drainage Systems (SuDS) manage water at or near its source, in order to slow down or stop the water entering the drainage system.
The project undertook a literature review, case study reviews and cost benefit analysis to consider the following key issues:
- What are the multiple benefits of source control SuDS and suitability for different urban land types?
- What are the barriers to adopting these solutions at both residential and community property level?
- What are the opportunities and recommendations for overcoming these barriers?
This project has completed. Click here to visit the publication page to view the project outputs.
Tackling water & environment challenges is a win-win
There is no escaping the fact that we are facing serious global challenges when it comes to water. Growing populations, climate-change driven extreme weather events that result in shocks to our natural and built environment, depleted groundwater supplies, pollution from agriculture, industry and sewage… the list goes on.
And yes, even Scotland, a country with an ambition to become the first Hydro Nation for its clean, abundant water resources that contributes to a vibrant economy, is not immune to these challenges, with 34% of its waterbodies failing to achieve good standards.
As it’s World Water Week this week (August 20-24), I want to take the opportunity to reflect on what those challenges are, but also what we can do about them.
The reality is that climate change remains the single greatest, long-term threat that we face, and the impacts are being increasingly felt in Scotland. For example, this summer’s extremely dry June compounded the problems of already low ground water levels.
Whilst the unusually wet July that followed, may have partially offset a potentially serious situation, the threat to water reserves persists with the number of extreme drought events in Scotland potentially increasing from an average of one every 20 years to one every three years.
These mean that communities can experience a lack of water, particularly where there is a reliance on private water supplies, and there is a clear need for more research to underpin strategic planning in this area.
On the other hand, we are also witnessing an increase in severe wet weather events, like Storm Frank and Arwen, meaning that households and businesses, as well as our natural environments, are being impacted by flooding. The extremes bite at both ends and this trend looks set only to increase.
But, taking water scarcity and flooding as an example, there is an opportunity to address these issues together, while also realising wider environmental, social and economic benefits.
The first step in addressing these issues is to better understand the nature of the problem. To do this, scientists here at The James Hutton Institute are looking at regional differences in and vulnerability to water scarcity across Scotland, including how rapidly the situation can deteriorate and recover.
This is critical to major Scottish industries that rely on these resources, from farming to whisky production, to be able plan and manage their operations.
Alongside this work, other studies at the Hutton are focusing on novel approaches to flood management, such as nature-based solutions. These are where more natural environments like ponds or wetlands are reinstated or created. These aim to provide water storage in river catchment areas, with the potential to recharge groundwater, slow river flows, reduce flooding and provide a vital water resource for people and wildlife during periods of water scarcity.
These are examples of some of the coordinated research that brings scientists from a wide range of disciplines together to find innovative solutions to protect people, businesses and support nature.
The Scottish Government understands that effective approaches to water and catchment management doesn’t just happen without significant leadership and coordination. That’s why, through its Hydro Nation agenda, it is supporting centres of expertise such CREW (the Centre of Expertise for Waters and Scotland’s Hydro Nation International Centre. These organisations, based at the Hutton, are responsible for building the necessary partnerships between talented natural and social scientists and engineers together with policy makers, planners, practitioners, and stakeholders – all sharing their knowledge, skills and expertise to address the many complex challenges facing the water sector today.
Looking forward, effective partnerships like these will be fundamental to policy success in areas such as the management of other new and increasing challenges, such as the growing range and mix of chemicals, pharmaceuticals and contaminants entering our waters. But there’s also a need to reduce surface flooding in urbans areas and support the just transition from fossil fuels to alternatives like hydrogen energy. Our water plays a key role in all these areas. Through working in partnership, Scotland, as a Hydro Nation, is ideally positioned to address these challenges and be a leader in transformative change in the worldwide water sector.